Follow my blog with Bloglovin

When it comes to eye makeup, the question of whether to apply eyeliner or mascara first has sparked numerous debates among beauty enthusiasts.

In this comprehensive blog post, we will dive deep into this age-old dilemma, providing insights into the pros and cons of each approach, expert tips on application techniques, and guidelines to help you achieve flawless eye makeup.

Let’s unravel the mystery and discover the perfect sequence for your eye-enhancing ritual.

The Case for Applying Eyeliner First

One school of thought advocates for applying eyeliner first as the foundation of your eye makeup. By starting with eyeliner, you establish the framework for your eye look, defining the shape and adding depth to your eyes.

This approach allows for better precision, ensuring clean lines and preventing the mascara from smudging onto your liner. Additionally, applying eyeliner first allows you to adjust the thickness and intensity according to your desired look.

The Benefits of Mascara as the Finishing Touch

Alternatively, some makeup enthusiasts prefer to save mascara for the final step of their eye makeup routine. By applying mascara last, you can enhance your lashes and bring the entire look together.

Mascara adds volume, length, and curl, creating a wide-eyed effect that beautifully complements your eyeliner and eyeshadow. This approach ensures that your lashes stand out and adds a touch of drama to complete your eye makeup masterpiece.

Application Techniques: Mastering the Sequence

To achieve flawless eye makeup, mastering the sequence of eyeliner and mascara application is crucial. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you navigate the process:

Eyeliner: Begin by selecting your preferred eyeliner type, such as a pencil, gel, or liquid.

Starting from the inner corner of your eye, apply the eyeliner along your lash line, gradually building the desired thickness and extending the line to create a winged effect if desired. Ensure a steady hand and smooth strokes for precise application.

Eyeshadow: If you plan to apply eyeshadow, do so after eyeliner and before mascara. This allows you to blend and layer the shades seamlessly while maintaining the crispness of your eyeliner.

Mascara: After allowing the eyeliner and eyeshadow (if applicable) to dry, move on to mascara. Open your mascara tube and wipe off any excess product on a tissue or the tube’s rim.

Starting from the base of your lashes, wiggle the mascara wand back and forth, sweeping it upward to coat the lashes evenly. Apply multiple coats as desired, allowing each layer to dry slightly before adding more.

Finishing Touches: Once your mascara has dried, you can opt to refine your eyeliner or add any final touches to your eye makeup, such as tightlining or applying a highlighter to the inner corners of your eyes.

Factors to Consider: Eye Shape and Personal Preference

When deciding whether to apply eyeliner or mascara first, it’s essential to consider your eye shape and personal preference.

Certain eye shapes may benefit from applying eyeliner first to enhance their natural contours, while others may find that starting with mascara creates a more balanced and impactful look.

Experimentation is key to discovering the approach that suits your unique features and desired aesthetic.

Tips for a Seamless Eye Makeup Application

To ensure a seamless eye makeup application, here are some additional tips to keep in mind:

Preparation is key: Cleanse and moisturize your eye area before applying any makeup to create a smooth canvas.

Invest in quality products: Choose high-quality eyeliner and mascara that suit your needs and preferences. This will make the application process easier and result in a more polished look.

Practice makes perfect: Experiment with different techniques and products to find what works best for you. Don’t be afraid to step out of your comfort zone and try new styles.

Maintain hygiene: Regularly clean your makeup brushes and replace mascaras and eyeliners as recommended to prevent eye infections.

Be patient: Take your time during application, especially when creating precise lines or building mascara volume. Rushing can lead to mistakes or clumping.


In the eternal debate of eyeliner or mascara first, there is no definitive answer that suits everyone. The choice ultimately depends on personal preference, eye shape, and desired effects.

By considering these factors and mastering the application techniques, you can achieve stunning eye makeup looks that enhance your natural beauty and reflect your unique style.

Embrace the versatility of eye makeup and let your creativity soar, whether you choose to start with eyeliner or save mascara for the grand finale.

Related Articles